The Blackthorn Key by Kevin Sands

In 1665, Christopher Rowe is an orphan and apprentice to Master Benedict Blackthorn, one of London’s many apothecaries and a kind and generous master to boot. However, when a secretive cult of murderous men begins to pick off the apothecaries Of London one by one, Christopher and his friend Tom, the baker’s son, must depend on one another and their wits to save themselves from becoming the next victims.

NOTICE: MY REVIEW MAY CONTAIN SPOILERS, DEPENDING ON WHAT YOU CONSIDER A SPOILER.

I really enjoyed this tale of adventure and derring-do right up to the climax of the story when Christopher and Tom discover that the murderers, and Master Blackthorn and pretty much everyone else in the story are all after the same thing: the formula for the Archangel’s Fire, a powerful alchemic concoction that will enable its finder to rule the world! (Insert manic laughter.) At that point the story became a little too Raiders-of-the-Lost-Ark for me: trivializing holy things while using them as a magical MacGuffin.

The denouement is fairly satisfying, perhaps leaving room for a sequel. The trouble is that I’m not sure I want a sequel, even though I enjoyed the novel itself. I guess I just didn’t like the idea of the Archangel’s Fire, a powerful and explosive manifestation of “God’s power unchecked”, as originally (supposedly) given to the Archangel Michael. Maybe it’s a matter of personal taste.

And I didn’t much like the revelation of who the main villain was either. The book takes place in the seventeenth century: Puritans and Cavaliers, Royalists and Roundheads. Which group do you think the villain belongs to, of course? I’m just sort of tired of rabid Puritan villains. Wouldn’t it be a change to have a villain from the other side?

Anyway, I’m sounding as if I didn’t like this story, and I actually enjoyed it a lot. Go back to the first paragraph, and if the premise sounds interesting, you should check it out.

Cast Off by Eve Yohalem

Cast Off: The strange adventures of Petra de Winter and Bram Broen by Eve Yohalem.

1663. Twelve year old Petra de Winter has stowed away on The Golden Lion, a Dutch merchant ship in the harbor of Amsterdam. She is determined to escape her abusive father, but as the ship leaves harbor on its way to the Cape of Good Hope and thence on to the East indies, Petra realizes that she cannot remain hidden on her own. It’s up to Bram Broen, son of the ship’s carpenter, half Dutch and Half Javanese, to show Petra how she can manage to evade capture and survive the coming months at sea.

It’s obvious that Ms. Yohalem did her research for this sea-faring adventure novel. Indeed, she says in the author’s note at the end of the book that her corollary to the old adage that an author should write what she knows is that “it’s okay to write what you don’t know; just make sure you do a lot of research.” She goes on to write, “Details about housekeeping, clothing, decor, Dutch fastidiousness, . . . food and medicine are all authentic. Whether the streets were brick or dirt, the ten p.m. curfew—all true in 1600’s Amsterdam.” And as far as I can tell, she goes on to get the nautical details right, too. The ship and its crew and the battle scene (yes, there’s a battle with pirates!) and all medical jargon felt right and was worked into the story in such an interesting and intriguing manner that I forgot I was getting a history lesson as I read.

The story is told in alternating voices, first by Petra, and then by Bram. There are class differences between the two children, as well as the obvious gender and cultural differences. Petra is the daughter of a wealthy merchant, but she’s developed a tough enduring spirit as a result of the abuse she has suffered from her father. Bram grew up barefoot and free on the island of Java, and then after his mother died, he became his father’s assistant on the ship, unable to leave the ship anywhere in Europe because of his mixed-race status. It takes time and work for the two to become friends and allies, but they do come to understand and support each other.

The ending was a little abrupt. Maybe the author intended to leave room for a sequel? If so, I’ll be interested to find out what happens to Petra and to Broem next. If not, I wish them well in their new life.

Last week was the week of World War 2 historical fiction and nonfiction. This week I think we’ll be taking a journey back to seventeenth century Europe. Some time this week, I’ll try to suggest some books that I’ve read in the past that take place in 1600’s Europe. Do you have any favorites from that time period?

Saturday Review of Books: October 24, 2015

“To buy books would be a good thing if we also could buy the time to read them.” ~Arthur Schopenhauer

SatReviewbutton

Welcome to the Saturday Review of Books at Semicolon. Here’s how it usually works. Find a book review on your blog posted sometime during the previous week. The review doesn’t have to be a formal sort of thing. You can link to your thoughts on a particular book, a few ideas inspired by reading the book, your evaluation, quotations, whatever.

Then on Friday night/Saturday, you post a link here at Semicolon in Mr. Linky to the specific post where you’ve written your book review. Don’t link to your main blog page because this kind of link makes it hard to find the book review, especially when people drop in later after you’ve added new content to your blog. In parentheses after your name, add the title of the book you’re reviewing. This addition will help people to find the reviews they’re most interested in reading.

After linking to your own reviews, you can spend as long as you want reading the reviews of other bloggers for the week and adding to your wishlist of books to read.

You can go to this post for over 100 links to book lists for the end of 2014/beginning of 2015. Feel free to add a link to your own list.

If you enjoy the Saturday Review of Books at Semicolon, please invite your friends to stop by and check out the review links here each Saturday.

What if I’m an Atheist? by David Seidman

What if I’m an atheist: a teen’s guide to exploring life without religion by David Seidman.

“A book is the only place in which you can examine a fragile thought without breaking it, or explore an explosive idea without fear it will go off in your face. It is one of the few havens remaining where a man’s mind can get both provocation and privacy.” ~Edward P. Morgan

While I think atheism is a “fragile idea” and not finally intellectually viable, it is an idea that many of us feel obligated to explore at one time or another. Mr. Seidman gives teenage atheists and agnostics the support and encouragement they might need to explore the idea of living without belief in God or religion in a 192 page book. He also encourages teens who are drawn to the idea of becoming a nonbeliever to be confident but kind, to stand up for their own beliefs without denigrating those who believe in some kind of religious dogma, and to be open to the possibility that their own beliefs may change as they grow older.

Mr. Seidman uses lots of quotes from actual teen atheists, mostly from internet forums and blog sites, as well as quotes from Christian apologists and others who have weighed in on what it means to be an atheist. Some of those who are quoted are bitter, harsh, and judgmental, but the tone of the book is not. He tells stories about teens who have been persecuted for their stand against religion and about teens who have faced difficult relationship breakdowns with family and friends. He gives some basic information on how to answer common questions from an atheistic point of view, and the answers are generally logical and respectful to a religious point of view, if not entirely complete or convincing. There’s even a chapter that gives advice on what to do if you find yourself returning to belief in religion after a period of atheism, although disappointingly the re-conversion stories mostly feature emotional leaps of faith rather than intellectual and spiritual journeys to faith.

On Goodreads, the author information about Mr. Seidman says, “David Seidman is a Los Angeles–area journalist, editor, and author who often writes nonfiction for teens. He comes to the topic of atheism with empathy for teenagers and for people in the religious minority, but he’s nobody’s advocate.” I don’t know if the author is an atheist himself, or a freethinker, or a born again Christian. The book itself is emphatically NOT an apologetic for Christianity or for atheism, but it does provide that “safe place” for exploration. And it lists some resources—books, websites, radio, TV, in-person meeting places, even college scholarships for atheists—where teens can get more information.

The Psalmist in Psalm 14:1 writes, “The fool has said in his heart, ‘There is no God.'” I agree with that assessment of atheism. However, who among us has not played the fool at one time or another in our lives? And what does the “fool” need? Wisdom, of course. We don’t get that from arguments or harsh or mocking words, but maybe if someone were to walk along alongside, listen, and love us, it would open our eyes to God’s love and God’s wisdom. This book, although it’s not at all Christian, could be a start on that journey or an encouragement for anyone who decides to remain on the road of life without God.

The Amazing Age of John Roy Lynch by Chris Barton

“John Roy Lynch had an Irish father and an enslaved mother. By the law of the South before the Civil War, that made John Roy and his brother half Irish and all slave.”

John Roy Lynch was a field slave who became a photographer, then Justice of the Peace, then Speaker of the Mississippi House of Representatives, and then a U.S. Representative. His climb from slavery to Congress is chronicled in Chris Barton’s book, The Amazing Age of John Roy Lynch.

Reconstruction (and the Gilded Age that followed it) are a rather neglected time period in American history for children, especially as it pertains to books set in the South. I have two shelves of books on the Civil War in my library, where the books, historical fiction and nonfiction, are shelved in chronological order. Between 1866 and the beginning of the twentieth century, I do have a shelf full of books, but none of them are set in the South. Most of the books that have to do with that time period are all about prairie settlers, cowboys, and heading west. Even the textbooks dance past Reconstruction with a little information about Andrew Johnson’s impeachment and black codes and then take a sharp turn immediately westward.

Mr. Barton’s picture book biography of one of the first black men to serve as a Representative to the U.S. House of Representatives, from the great state of Mississippi, fills a hole in the living history books available to children and fills it well. The text is simple, but honest, and it doesn’t gloss over the fact that the Klan was active and the Civil War was not really over in a sense during the time that John Roy Lynch served as a U.S. Representative. The basic information about the difficulties of slavery and its aftermath, terrorism and persecution for black people, is conveyed in story form, making those facts both more horrible (these things happened to real people!) and more understandable and even hopeful (brave and intelligent people tried to make things better) at the same time.

John Roy Lynch himself is an inspiring and admirable character. He pursued an education in his “spare time” and taught himself by eavesdropping on a school across the alleyway. He became a photographer by way of on-the-job training. He taught himself the law so that he could be a just Justice of the Peace. He became a landowner, and then a public servant in the state legislature, then in the U.S. House. And he did all of these things while he was still in his twenties.

Although Congressman Lynch was defeated for re-election in 1876 as Reconstruction came to a close and the South returned to a new era of black subjugation and disenfranchisement, his words continued to inspire, and he “continued to believe that the laws of this land could bring about justice.”

“When every man, woman, and child can feel that his, her, and their rights are fully protected by the strong arm of a generous and grateful Republic, then we can all truthfully say that this beautiful land of ours, over which the Star Spangled Banner so triumphantly waves, is, in truth and in fact, the ‘land of the free and the home of the brave.'” ~John Roy Lynch, 1874

Unlikely Warrior by Georg Rauch

Unlikely Warrior: A Jewish Soldier in Hitler’s Army by Georg Rauch.

Because Austrian Georg Rauch had a Jewish grandmother, making him one quarter Jewish blood (whatever that means), he was not made an officer in the army of the Third Reich. However, Rauch’s Jewish ancestry didn’t prevent him from being drafted into the German army and sent as a radio operator to the Russian front. Rauch wasn’t a Nazi nor was he in sympathy with Hitler’s political views or his plan for European domination. But that lack of patriotic enthusiasm didn’t keep nineteen year Georg Rauch from being expected to serve the Fuehrer and fight for the cause of Germany.

It must be World War 2 week here at Semicolon; it seems I’ve unintentionally been reading quite a few books set during that cataclysmic war. On Sunday I reviewed FDR and the American Crisis by Albert Marrin. On Monday, I told you about my pastor’s World War 2 novel, We Never Stood Alone, about the inhabitants of the English village of Stokeley and their more personal crises during the first years of the war. Yesterday I wrote about the young adult adaptation of Laura Hillenbrand best-selling and eye-opening biography of Louis Zamperini, Unbroken. And now today we’re headed for the eastern front, in Ukraine and Romania, where the cruelties and atrocities were, according to Mr. Rauch, just as abominable as the things Zamperini had to endure in Japan and in the South Pacific. (Comparisons are odious, but sometimes inevitable.)

By 1943, again from Rauch’s point of view, the average German soldier on the eastern front knew that the Germans were losing the war. Rauch just hoped to survive long enough to be sent home when the Germans finally surrendered. Unfortunately for him, as the war was ending Rauch was captured by the Russians and spent a good year or more in successive Soviet labor camps before he managed to finagle a place on a train back to his homeland of Austria.

As I read this book and Zamperini’s story in Unbroken, I found it difficult to believe that men could survive such horrors and emerge sane or even alive. Many did not survive, and many more did not survive in spirit. I wonder if I have what it would take to survive in such horrendous circumstances, and I really doubt that I do. If I were ever confronted with such a crisis as the Christians of Syria and Iraq are living through now, I would have to depend on the Holy Spirit to sustain me or the Lord would have to take me, because I certainly don’t have it within me to endure such persecution.

I’m rather amazed that anyone does. Unlikely Soldier is a good book about a bad time. I recommend it to adults, young and old, who are interested in an unflinching look at the horrors of war from a unique perspective, that of an unwilling conscript in Hitler’s army.

Unbroken by Laura Hillenbrand

Unbroken: An Olympian’s Journey from Airman to Castaway to Captive, Adapted for Young Adults by Laura Hillenbrand.

I first read Unbroken, the life history of Olympic runner and prisoner of war in Japan, Louis Zamperini, in 2011, about four years ago. I was astounded and moved by this man’s story then, and as I’ve read more about him since then, I continue to be an admirer of and and an advocate for Hillenbrand’s book, Unbroken.

So, I read the young adult adaptation of one of my favorite books with both a desire to see it succeed and with some trepidation. It helps that this version of Unbroken was in capable hands, the hands of the original author Laura Hillenbrand herself. And honestly, although I could tell that the book had been shortened and that the text had been somewhat simplified, I couldn’t pinpoint anything that was left out. That makes for an excellent adaptation.

It also means that if you were looking for a book that leaves out all the violence and cruelty and general horror of Louis Zamperini’s stay in various Japanese prisoner of war camps, this book doesn’t do that. The book also doesn’t leave out Louis’s struggle with PTSD and his healing after the war as the movie version did. So, if your young adult, age twelve and above, wants a less intimidating version, i.e. fewer pages and no footnotes at the end, that still tells the whole story, this book will do the job. If your child is not ready for an introduction to the horrors of man’s inhumanity and cruelty, this book definitely won’t be a good choice.

Two of my own children read Unbroken (the adult version) while they were still in high school, and they found it accessible and absorbing. However, if your teen struggles with reading long books or just is in a time crunch, this young adult adaptation is well written and perfectly adequate. It’s not dumbed down, and the writing is still beautiful, detailed, and vivid.

I recommend Unbroken, either version, to just about anyone who’s interested in history or war or survival or World War 2 in particular or inspiring biography or the aftermath of war and the possibility of forgiveness. I’ll be looking for a copy of this young adult version to place in my library for younger teen readers.

We Never Stood Alone by Bob DeGray

If you like both World War II fiction and Christian fiction, We Never Stood Alone should be your next read, for sure. My pastor wrote the book, so maybe I’m prejudiced, but I found it absorbing, impeccably researched, and also full of spiritual and practical truth. I certainly can’t say all three of those things about many books that I read.

The novel is set in the fictional village of Stokely on the Thames River in south central England in 1939 as war clouds loom on the horizon. Free Church pastor Lloyd Robins, worrying over the continual drumbeat of bad news from the continent and the ringing in his bad ear, is trying to remain faithful to the Lord he came to know in the last war and hopeful in the face of the coming storm. His wife, Annie, is his support, but she has her own struggles and storms to walk through. Both Lloyd and Annie, as well as the other members of Stokely Free Church, must learn to sense the indwelling of the Holy Spirit as they necessarily depend on Him in a time of profound danger and uncertainty.

Yes, there are those many, many other members of Stokely Free Church and other inhabitants of the village of Stokely. You almost need a list of characters to keep them all straight, and obliging author that he is, Mr. DeGray has provided just such a list on his blog, World War 2 Christian Fiction. Consult the list when you read, as needed.

When I read good books, I am usually reminded of other good books or movies or even TV series. We Never Stood Alone reminded me both of Downton Abbey and of Jan Karon’s Mitford/Father Tim books. The Downton Abbey connection is, of course, found in the sheer British-ness of the setting and characters as well as the intertwined stories of all the village people in community. Community is a central theme of the book as is the daily efficacy of prayer and Scripture, two Christian disciplines which also intertwine to keep us in community and in Christ’s presence. In this theme of Christian community among broken and average people, the village and people of Stokely in We Never Stood Alone most resemble Jan Karon’s Mitford community of normal, everyday people in the process of being transformed by a loving and immanent God.

To learn more about the book or the author or both, visit the author’s website, ww2christianfiction.com.

To purchase your copy, either as an ebook or in print, try Amazon.

FDR and the American Crisis by Albert Marrin

History professor Albert Marrin has been writing nonfiction narrative history for quite a while: his first book for young adults was Overlord: D Day and the Invasion of Europe, which was published in 1982. He has written more than thirty history narratives for children and young adults, including Flesh and Blood So Cheap: The Triangle Fire and Its Legacy, a National Book Award finalist.

In his latest book, Marrin returns to the World War II era and to the Great Depression and to the president who shepherded America through both of those crises, Franklin Delano Roosevelt. FDR was a complicated character, and Mr. Marrin presents him—warts, strengths, and all—in the context of the events and attitudes of his time. FDR and The American Crisis is, above all, a comprehensive and balanced vision of Roosevelt, what he did for the United States and what he did to change the country, for better and for worse.

In addition to my appreciation for its even-handedness, I was most impressed with the personal tone of Mr. Marrin’s very detailed, yet broad, narrative. Mr. Marrin is 79 years old. Born in 1936, he actually remembers some of the events of Roosevelt’s presidency and of the second World War. And he’s not afraid to gently insert himself into the narrative with an “I remember” or a “we all wonder if” statement. In addition, Marrin isn’t reluctant to share his own informed opinion when it’s appropriate:

“Critics branded Hoover a ‘do-nothing’ president who let Americans suffer due to his commitment to old-fashioned ideas. It is untrue.”

“The media developed a teenager’s crush on the Red Army.”

“Convinced of his own virtue and wisdom, he (FDR) thought too highly of his personal charm and powers of persuasion. He misjudged the murderous Stalin.”

“Those who praised him (FDR) as a saintly miracle worker are as wrong as those who bitterly cursed him as a monster.”

Bottom line, I learned a lot from reading FDR and the American Crisis—and I learned it in a throughly pleasant and absorbing read. Mr. Marrin once said in an interview, “Kids are very bright. I’m not going to write down. If anything, I’ll have them read up to me.” This book is not dumbed down, nor is it a breezy hagiography of a famous president. Any high school, or even college, student looking for both an in-depth and readable introduction to FDR and his presidency could not do better than to read Mr. Marrin’s book first.

Book Advisory

I’ve been having fun recommending books to people who ask for specific recommendations in the Read Aloud Revival Facebook group and the Ambleside Online Facebook group as well as on my Facebook feed. I thought I’d share some of the requests and recommendations here, just for fun.

Request: Favorite living books about seeds, trees and/or early botany for children ages 7, 5 and 2.

Suggestions:
More Potatoes by Millicent Selsam.
A Tree Is a Plant by Clyde Robert Bulla.
Mighty Tree by Dick Gackenbach.
Seeds and More Seeds by Millicent Selsam.
How a Seed Grows by Helene J. Jordan.
From Seed to Plant by Gail Gibbons.
The Reason for a Flower by Ruth Heller.
Plants That Never Ever Bloom by Ruth Heller.
A Tree Is Nice by Janice May Udry.
The Plant Sitter by Gene Zion.
A Seed Is Sleepy by Diana Aston.
The Tree Lady: The True Story of How One Tree-Loving Woman Changed a City Forever by H. Joseph Hopkins.
The Poppy Seeds by Clyde Robert Bulla.

Request: LONG picture books or beginning chapter books for a three year old who will sit and listen for an hour at a time.

Suggestions:
Obadiah the Bold by Brinton Turkle.
Frog and Toad by Arnold Lobel.
Little Bear by Else Holmelund Minarik.
Billy and Blaze by C.W. Anderson.
Yonie Wondernose by Marguerite deAngeli.
Make Way for Ducklings by Robert McCloskey.
Mother West Wind’s Children by Thornton Burgess.
All of these books, except for the one by de Angeli, have sequels, so if you like the first one there are more.

Request: Books for a five year old girl in first grade, but reading at about a second grade level.

Suggestions:
Amanda Pig books by Jean Van Leeuwen.
Mr. Putter and Tabby books by Cynthia Rylant.
Thimbleberry Stories by Cynthia Rylant.
The Boxcar Children by Gertrude Chandler Warner.
The Secret of the Rosewood Box and other mysteries by Helen Fuller Orton.
The Great Cake Mystery: Precious Ramotswe’s Very First Case by Alexander McCall Smith.
26 Fairmount Avenue by Tomie de Paola.
In Aunt Lucy’s Kitchen (Cobblestone Cousins) by Cynthia Rylant.
Those last three were suggested by Heidi Dunbar Scovel who blogs at Mt. Hope Chronicles, a wonderful resource for good book suggestions.

Request: Good books for young (8 and 9 year old) Harry Potter fans.

Suggestions:
The Wingfeather Saga by Andrew Peterson.
100 Cupboards by N.D. Wilson.
The Mysterious Benedict Society by Trenton Stewart.
Redwall series by Brian Jacques.
The Phantom Tollbooth by Norman Juster.
The Return of the Twelves by Pauline Clarke.
Tom’s Midnight Garden by Phillippa Pearce.
The Thief by Megan Whalen Turner.
The False Prince by Jennifer Neilsen.

Do you have any reader’s advisory requests, for adults or children? Bring it on. I really enjoy suggesting and pushing books.