Vampire Love by Libby Gruner, an essay at Literary Mama on the sources for the popularity of Stephanie Meyer’s series:
Vampire stories are, of course, perfect for teenagers. Vampires stay out all night, scare the respectable citizens, take crazy risks, and live, seemingly, forever. And they’re both sexy and dangerous. Their feasting is intimate, and it’s transformative: the first time matters. Vampire stories come and go, but they’ve been particularly popular among teenagers, it seems to me, during the age of AIDS: they titillate with their suggestion of a sweet fatality borne in the blood, but they also — in the Twilight series especially — carry a strong message of abstinence.”
I read Twilight, New Moon and Eclipse last month, one after the other, like candy, in the course of two or three days. Two of my daughters had the books, purchased with their own money, and I read them mostly to see what the fuss was about. Just like candy, I found them fairly harmless, but not terribly nutritious. Eldest Daughter read the first book in the series, Twilight, and found it to be repetitive and somewhat emotionally overwrought. I couldn’t disagree with her assessment, but it didn’t bother me as much as it did her. I just kept reading, eager to find out how Bella and her vampire boy friend would resolve their essential, life-threatening dilemma: how do you love someone who’s seriously tempted to kill you and drink your blood every time he gets close to you? Or if you’re Edward the Reformed Vampire who’s made a promise not to drink human blood, even though he needs blood to survive and craves human blood, how do you have an intimate relationship with the love of your life without killing her?
There are, of course, other difficulties and plot predicaments: bad, unreformed vampires, werewolves in the second book, Bella’s own clumsiness and stubbornness, Edward’s rectitude and his family of good, but tempted, vampires, a sort of Vampire Capital of the World where the vampires are bloodthirsty and not afraid to show it., other guys who provoke Edward’s jealousy. Still, it all comes down to: how are Edward and Bella going to get together and survive the encounter?
Recommended, cautiously, for those young ladies who realize that these books are fantasy, not reality, and that they’re essentially light reading, not models for male/female relationships.
Great review. I think some people are reading way too much into these books. Just sit back and enjoy the little guilty pleasure!
I had a great time reading them. Yes, I was exasparated with Bella, charmed by Jacob and facsinated with Edward. It will be interesting to see how Meyers solves the dilemna in the fianl book.
Best vampire/human love story ever … Sunshine by Robin McKinley. Give it a try, keeping in mind all those disclaimers you made in the post. 😀
I love it. I just can’t get enough of the book I need that last book I can’t pick up another book until I have finished the series. I am in love with it all.
i think that th series is great. i love it! edward is so tempted to drink bella’s blood but he is so in love with her that he can’t live without her. and the conflicts between jacob, edward are so good i just can’t stop reading. and the conficts between bella and jacob reflect a normal teenage arguement between friends but only with a werewolf.
I absolutely love the Twighlight series! I’m addicted to them!
Pingback: Mommy Brain » Twilight
I’m searching the web for reviews of the books that include any reference to Meyer’s use of Native content. There’s a lot of it… I’m blogging about it on my site. americanindiansinchildrensliterature.blogspot.com
AIDS is a “sweet fatality?” I realize this is a book review, and I haven’t read the novel, but that comparison is just… unbelievably inappropriate and insulting.
Books-A-Million is hosting THE party of the Summer for all Twilight fans. Celebrate the midnight release of Breaking Dawn with Twilight trivia contests, costume contests, prizes, and much more! Party starts at 10pm on Friday, August 1st. Visit you local Books-A-Million to pre-purchase the book today and be the first in line to get Breaking Dawn at midnight, you won’t get it anywhere else faster!
Haven’t read the novel. It’s popularity makes me doubt whether it’s good so it’s popular or it’s popular so everybody thinks it’s good. Sorry, I’m an Anne Rice fan. Mushy romance, however presented, makes me queasy, and not in a good way. Peace. 🙂
The twilight series are one of the best series I have ever read! I give total thanks to Stephanie for thinking up something so brilliant and romantic. (I’m a sucker for romance stories.)
Pingback: Semicolon » Blog Archive » Graceling by Kristin Cashore