Archives

LOST Rehash: Greatest Hits, or Charlie’s Gotta Die and Jack’s Gotta Lead

Best lines from tonight’s episode:

 Charlie: “Why does everything have to be such a secret? How about some openness for a change?”

 Jack: “We’re gonna blow’em all to h—!”

Naomi to Charlie: “Look on the bright side. You’re not really dead, right?” (Heavy irony)

 Sayid to Jack: “You said you were our leader. It’s time for you to act like one.”

Charlie to Desmond: “We both know you’re not supposed to take my place.”

 I loved Charlie’s list. Could you list the five best moments of your life? I may think about that for another post. Anyway, Charlie’s best and brightest list was illuminating. Will God catch Charlie when he dies just as his father caught him in the pool? Is Charlie really a hero as the woman said? (Yes!) Is he a “bloody rock star” even though he’s only had one hit record?

Apparently, Charlie lives a little while longer anyway. I think he’s doomed, though. Who are those Commando Ladies? And what will happen to Charlie’s ring left in Aaron’s cradle? Will Desmond wake up in time to escape whatever is going to happen to Looking Glass station?

The season finale episode is named Through the Looking Glass in imitation of Alice’s second adventure. What will happen is anyone’s guess, but I’m predicting:

Charlie’s death.

Locke’s reappearance.

Ben’s capture and maybe death.

Desmond has a headache.

Juliet has to spill some more secrets.

Did you notice that Ben said that Jacob told him to move the timetable up on the kidnapping? I maintain that Ben no longer hears from Jacob, if he ever did, and he’s using Jacob’s name to keep his “cult” members in line and make them carry out his (Ben’s) wishes.

Oh, and Rose and Bernard are back. This reappearance makes me and Lindsey (Just Enjoy the Journey) happy. Locke’s reappearance will not make me happy. Jack did better this episode. At least, he listened to Sayid, the real brains of this operation. And Hurley, the Wise Fool, sensed something was going on with Charlie. If they ever kill off Hurley, I’m done. No more LOST. The writers and producers have been warned.

Thinkling De’s liveblogging LOST again.

LOST Rehash: The Man Behind the Curtain, or Ben Is the Wizard of Oz

SPOILERS: Do not enter. Pay no atention to the man behind the curtain unless you’ve already seen the May 9 episode of LOST.

The Wizard of Oz

So, Ben is the Wizard. And there’s no one behind the curtain, no Jacob, unless Jacob is an invisible poltergeist. I agree with Locke. Ben’s the Wizard of the Island, manipulating the curtain, producing his own special effects. And Ben, as I’ve said all along, ia a liar. However, just as there is in The Wizard of Oz, there is “magic” or something supernatural that supersedes Ben’s machinations. He was surprised that “Jacob” spoke to Locke, and now Ben realizes, if he didn’t already, that there are forces or personalities on this island that he doesn’t understand or control.

Jack, on the other hand, thinks he’s still in control. He finally has a plan that he deigns to share with the other Losties. They’re going to have a big battle, and Jack’s the general. Sayid couldn’t be trusted to take part in Jack’s wonderful planning process even though he’s the only one they’ve got who know anything about fighting battles. And no one else could be told until now either. (Can you hear the sarcasm in my writing?) I don’t know who Jack thinks he is, but we don’t have time to argue about it now. Live together, die alone—whatever that means. It’s time to circle the wagons and fight off the Others who are appaarently not Dharma folks, but rather “Hostiles.” Hostiles kidnap pregnant women. I think we’d better put a guard around Sun. And would somebody (Sun) please clue Jin in on what’s going on ASAP? They’re going to need all hands on deck. (I mix metaphors and cliches just as well as LOST mixes symbols and allusions.)

Symbols and stuff in this episode that I don’t really understand completely:

White rabbit: Why is Ben so fond of white rabbits? White Rabbit was the title of the episode in Season 1 when Jack kept seeing his dad —his dad who was already dead. In this episode, young Ben sees his mom —who is also supposed to be dead. Is this island a place where dead people who have unresolved issues with their kids re-appear as ghosts? Alice followed the White Rabbit in Wonderland. Ben sort of followed the White Rabbit into Hostile Land. Ben also used a white rabbit to con Sawyer into thinking that he had a pacemaker implant that would kill him if he got excited.

The empty rocking chair: Jacob is supposed to be in the rocking chair, but it reminds me of Psycho. I think Ben’s psychologically disturbed, probably as a result of his dead mom and verbally abusive dad.

Skeletons: Skeletons abound on this island. There are skeletons in the slave ship, skeletons fall out of airplanes and a VW van, and now we have skeletons in a pit. Is this the Island of Death? Are the skeletons meant to imply that the Losties are already dead, too, or that they will be soon? Doomed.

The pit: People die or sometimes live in pits on this island. Anna Lucia had Other Goodwin down in a pit. Nikki and Paolo died in a large grave/pit. Now Locke’s dying or dead in the pit along with a bunch of Dharma skeletons. Of course, the hatch which preoccupied all of us first season was just big pit which became a death trap. Only no one died? Didn’t Rousseau live in a large underground room or pit?

Alice in Wonderland. The Wizard of Oz. The Pit and the Pendulum. Psycho.
I think those stories about summarize tonight’s episode.

Next week: Apocalypse Now?

Shannon at Rocks in My Dryer: They Don’t Call it LOST for Nuthin’.

Amanda: The Wonderful Wizard of Lost.

Olive: Ben’s as crazy as we thought.

LOST Rehash: The Brig, or Who’s In Prison?

Brigantine Built in Nova Scotia in 1861
WARNING: SPOILERS AHEAD! You say, I can’t do that: don’t tell me what I can’t do!

I. don’t. get. it.

O.K., it’s called “The Brig.” A brig is a ship’s prison. Obviously, Locke locked his daddy up in the brig, and James/Sawyer was locked up, too. James has also been “imprisoned” in his revenge, and now he’s free? Are all the LOSTies in the brig, so to speak? Imprisoned on the island until they work out their own salvation with fear and trembling? We’re back to purgatory. Locke’s dad Sawyer thought they were all dead and in hell, but if someone’s already dead, how could James/Sawyer kill him?

I don’t think they’re in hell or in purgatory.

Why did The Others want Locke to kill his dad? And why didn’t Locke either do the deed or tell Ben and The Others to go jump in the lake? If Locke’s capable of finding his own private assassin and sitting outside listening while Assassin James strangles his dad, why couldn’t he just do it himself. Why does the whole plot remind me of a Greek play? Not Oedipus, but some other Greek play where a guy is supposed to kill his father out of revenge? Locke’s on his own journey. O.K., Locke is a loose cannon, no more to be trusted than is Jack.

Is Kate an idiot? She decides to tell Jack about Parachute Girl, Naomi, and then because Juliet won’t leave immediately, Kate blurts out everything to both of them. Again, is Kate an idiot?

Is Naomi telling the truth? I rather doubt it. I think she’s a plant. Maybe she’s one of the Others or someone sent by the Dharma folks to spy on them. That communication device isn’t going to work.

Oh, nice touch, Sawyer’s fake name was “Tom Sawyer,” the ultimate con artist. Tom Sawyer was really interested in pirate ships and kidnapping people and finding treasure, too.

LOST Rehash: D.O.C., or Dead or CompletelyDead

What does D.O.C. stand for? I must be acronym-impaired.
There wasn’t any time for literary references in this episode. It was an action packed hour.

My Like list: Hurley‘s still Numero Uno. “Oops!” he said when he shot off the flare. He knew they needed help, and he knew excatly what he was doing to summon some help. And did he try to use the phone to call his mom?
Desmond also knew what had to be done and did it. Promise the guy whatever he wants to get medical attention for Miss Multilingual Parachutist. And he told Charlie the truth, “You’ve killed more of Them than have have of you.” How many Others have the Losties killed (not counting Mr. Eyepatch Mikhail)? Ethan, What’s His Name from the Pit that Ana Lucia killed, the lady that Sun shot, and Whosit that they killed while escaping from the little island. Is that all? Anyway, Desmond’s right; they need to keep their word, not go around gauging out eyes. Bad Charlie!
Sun is a fine lady —even if she does come from a Korean Mafia family. She knows that you should never pay blackmail —unless it’s your mother-in-law that’s doing the blackmailing. And then you tell her to be satisfied with the $100.000 or else your Mafia daddy will get her. Are there any good dads in this story? Are there any good moms? Good parents at all?
Jin: Did you see those martial arts moves? Jin has the skills to be running this island, but unfortunately he can’t effectively communicate with anyone except his wife.

Bad List: Sun’s right. Jack is acting strange(ly). Charlie is also acting strangely. Maybe he thinks he’s going to die any minute, and it’s making him a little jumpy. It would make me a little nervous. Still, he needs to settle down and quit talking about poking someone’s eye out.
Mikhail does not seem like a nice guy to me. Ben indicated that he was trigger-happy, and he’s a phone thief, too. How did he come back from the dead? Didn’t Kate or Locke or someone check to see if he was really dead?

Ambivalent List: Juliet looked truthfully happy (not fake, smarmy happy) when she and Sun saw the baby on the ultrasound. What kind of samples is she getting from the other women? Pregnancy test samples? Or the samples they took from Walt? Didn’t they? So she hates Ben? That’s a point in her favor.
Kate is too clean and well-groomed to be living on an island. And I’m tired of her ambivalence, so I’m ambivalent about her—even though she didn’t have much to do in this episode.

I’m reading elsewhere that the Purgatory Theory is back in full force in light of the final revelation at the end of the show that the LOST guys were really lost, or rather dead. So did they recover any bodies because it seems to me that the only people who stay dead on this island are those whose bodies are actually buried in the ground?
Shannon at Rocks in my Dryer: “And Then There Are the Days When a Strange Woman Parachutes Out of the Sky To Tell You That You Are, In Fact, Dead.”

The Thinklings: De liveblogging the episode with pertinent comments.

LOST Rehash: Catch-22, or Mt. Moriah Here We Come


So Brown Bear Daughter and I are caught up on back LOST episodes, and we watched the one tonight.

***********SPOILER ALERT***************
I’ll start with my good list/bad list.
LIKE: Hurley, my Number One Best Guy on the Island, Jin telling ghost stories in Korean, Sayid, still the most level-headed of all the men on the island, Spunky Sun, Rose (I want her back).

DISLIKE: Locke the Loser, Kate the User, Jack the Sap, Juliet the Spy.

AMBIVALENT: Charlie (kind of whiny but still cute), Claire (a good match for Charlie), Desmond (still running), Sawyer. I like Sawyer With Attitude, but Sawyer Mooning Over Kate is a little hard to stomach.

Ben’s in a class by himself. What a complicated character! Could he really be as omniscient as he appears to be? Definitely not likeable, but Ben’s keeping the whole story going.

Joseph Heller and Catch-22. Has anyone here read Catch-22? I haven’t although I know the basic meaning of the phrase; isn’t it supposed to be an Army term, d—— if you do, and d—- if you don’t? Desmond was in a bit of a sticky predicament. So if he hadn’t saved Charlie, would the parachutist have turned out to be Penny after all. Of course not. How many times can he manage to save Charlie’s life? Maybe Dominic wants off the show at the end of this season.

Why did the monks decide to “fire” Desmond? Because he drank a bottle of their best wine? Did I miss something there?

Desmond keeps having these visions. He’s a prophet, like Abraham. Maybe he keeps having the visions of Charlie’s death because he’s supposed to save Charlie’s life each time. Otherwise, it seems that if Someone really wanted Charlie to die, He’d quit sending the visions. Desmond’s never told NOT to save Charlie; what would you expect him to do? Or are the visions Satanic? Or is someone praying for Charlie? Poor Charlie. It might be hard to be Desmond, but it would really be a pain to be Charlie. I always thought Isaac had the more difficult test of trusting his father, too. After all, Abraham heard directly from God; Isaac had to trust that his dad wasn’t insane, climb up on the altar, and see the knife coming down.

I have some questions and observations abou the previous episodes, too. Did the Others take Locke’s father with them when they left? If so, why were they so reluctant to “forgive” Kate, who as far as I know had done nothing to them, and perfectly willing to take Locke’s dad, a nasty piece of work if I ever saw one?

The Nikki and Paolo episode was a detour, but it was a nice imitation of a murder mystery. I read that Sawyer was even reading an Agatha Christie mystery, Evil Under the Sun, during the episode.

Oh, and I knew that Juliet was evil from the beginning. I don’t know how evil she is; she may have been blackmailed into working with Ben. Nevertheless, she’s bad.

And Jack is blind. I hope Sayid decides to ask some questions—and get some answers. I’m worried about Sun’s pregnancy.

Previously on LOST

Druring Lent while I was taking a blogging break, Brown Bear Daughter and I also decided to forego television. Hence, no LOST.

So now we are trying to catch up. We just watched the episode where Nikki and Paolo are buried alive. I don’t want to know want happens next. I only have one question: is it just me, or do the Nikki and Paolo characters seem obviously shoe-horned into the whole saga? Has anyone else complained about this?

OK. I have another question. When you saw this particular episode, did you hope that the two of them would stay in the grave? ‘Cause I don’t like Miss Pouty-Face and Mr. Brazilian Gigolo.

To This Great Stage of Fools: Born February 16th

Henry Adams, b. 1838. He was the grandson of one president and the great-grandson of another. Numbered among his many friends were Lincoln’s private secretary John Hay, Henry Cabot Lodge, Theodore Roosevelt, geologist Clarence King, Senators Lucius Lamar and James Cameron, artist John La Farge, and writer Edith Wharton. His most famous work was an autobiography written in third person, The Education of Henry Adams. (online here) He also wrote and published many books about his extensive travels and about history.

The difference is slight, to the influence of an author, whether he is read by five hundred readers, or by five hundred thousand; if he can select the five hundred, he reaches the five hundred thousand.

LeVar Burton, b. 1957. Star and executive producer of the PBS series Reading Rainbow. We used to watch a lot of Reading Rainbow, and I still have quite a few episodes on videotape. Mr. Burton also starred as Geordie in Star Trek: The Next Generation, and he got his start as Kunta Kinte in the mini-series Roots, based on the book by the same name. How many of you read Roots when it was a best-seller, about thirty years ago? I remember it as a good story, and it won a Pulitzer Prize in 1976. However, in 1978 Mr. Haley was sued for plagiarizing several passages in his book from a book called The African by Harold Courlander. Haley admitted that he did copy Courlander’s work “unintentionally,” and the suit was settled out of court for $650,000.
It was still a good story, and Mr. Burton started a fine career with it. Thanks to Roots and its success as a TV-miniseries, we have Reading Rainbow, a good deal if you ask me.
“But you don’t have to take my word for it.”
Reading Rainbow Official website.
On January 29, 2007, LeVar Burton announced that he had made his last episode of Reading Rainbowand that he was retiring, citing a difference in vision with the new owners of the show. “Their vision was not in alignment with what I stand for,” he said.

LOST Rehash: Flashes Before Your Eyes

I want everybody to tell me I’m wrong —and why I’m wrong. However, I think the LOST guys have messed up big time. They haven’t read enough science fiction or theology. First of all, however, I give the obligatory SPOILER ALERT. Probably there are spoilers here. I don’t know. If we live in a self-correcting universe, then the spoilers get corrected, too. Right?

Either everything is predestined or determined or nothing is. A basic law of science fiction and of theological speculation is that you can’t have it both ways. Right? If the guy in the red shoes is meant to die under a falling building, then in a deterministic universe, he has to die under the building. He can’t die in a car wreck the next day, as the universe “self corrects,” because that would affect other people and their predetermined fates. What about the guy who’s driving the other car? Was he meant to kill Red Shoes in a car accident? Won’t the accident, or the lack thereof, affect his life in profound ways? If Charlie was supposed to be struck by lightning, then who was supposed to save Claire when she was drowning? Not Desmond; he just stepped in to save Charlie. Or was Claire supposed to drown? In that case, Claire’s fate is messed up, too, and the Universe will have to do some more self-correcting. The universe can’t “self correct.” There are too many factors. An impersonal force like the Universe can’t make everything work the way it’s supposed to as people make choices in opposition to the Will of the Universe. Shoot, the Universe can’t even have a will in the first place.

So maybe Desmond is crazy, and the universe is not predestined. Desmond is just using predestination or determinism as an excuse for his own cowardice. But that can’t be so because Desmond really is having flashes of true precognition. Claire really does almost drown. The soccer team on TV really does win the game. So Desmond must be seeing things that really are planned to happen or have already happened. By whom? The Universe? If so, why don’t they happen? How can Desmond prevent something that is supposed to happen without changing the Plan completely?

There is a Third Way. But I don’t think the writers of LOST have left room for a God who is in control of the Universe and yet allows human beings to make real choices. A God who is powerful enough and intelligent enough could weave corrections into the predetermined plan for the universe without making human choice into a farce. It’s the only path I see between determinism and chaos. But I’m no philosopher.

I’ve just read a little sci-fi and a lot of Bible.

Aside from all that philosophical junk, I think Desmond has a great accent. And Pen’s father is a particularly nasty villain —the kind everybody loves to hate. Very satisfying.

Oh, and they can’t kill off Charlie. If the Orcs couldn’t kill him and Saruman couldn’t get him, then what chance has a puny old universe that can’t even keep Desmond from buying a ring that he wasn’t supposed to buy? And if the universe self corrects, what was the white-haired lady so upset about? It would all get corrrected anyway, right?

I give this episode a C-. Was Henry supposed to die of cancer, and is Jack messing around with the universe?

“Que Sera, Sera,
Whatever will be, will be
The future’s not ours, to see
Que Sera, Sera
What will be, will be.”

(I wish I knew how to do accent marks. It bothers me to see it without the accents. Maybe the Universe will correct it for me.)

LOST Rehash: Not in Portland (nor in Kansas)

*******LOTS OF SPOILERS. CONSIDER YOURSELF WARNED ********


So Juliette wants to go home and see her sister’s baby. And Alex thinks she’s Ben’s daughter. (But I don’t.)

What else did we learn tonight on LOST?

Kate’s ruthless; Juliette’s ruthless. Sawyer’s a softie.

Somebody doesn’t do anesthesia too well.

Ben may or may not be Alex’s father, but he surely keeps a tight rein on her and won’t be happy if she leaves Alcatraz.

Alex has a boyfriend (Carl?) who is the subject of some very bizarre experiment or torture or something. What were some of those messages on the screen? God loves you as he loved Jacob. Think about your life. I can’t remember the rest, which means that I wouldn’t be a very good subject for their little experiment. I hope.

We’ll never know whether Jack would have let Ben die or not. Jack will never know whether he would have let Ben die on the operating table. Kate still doesn’t know whether she’s in love with Sawyer or with Jack. Sawyer’s not sure Kate has a heart at all; I’m not either.

Since the hatch exploded, they’re all stranded on the island, and I don’t think Ben can send Juliette home now. Unless he has a pair of ruby slippers in a closet somewhere.

Did anyone see who was in the “cheesy pictures” that the scary job recruiter guy showed Juliette to get her to come to “Portland”? Whay was it so great that Juliette’s sister could get pregnant? Because she had cancer? Or because she had other infertility problems? What’s up with the pregnant male mouse? And do the Others know that Sun is pregnant? If they do, she’s in danger because some of their research has to do with Juliette’s fertility experiments.

Tom seems like a nice guy. He’ll probably die soon.

Juliette’s been on the island for 3+ years. How long has Ben been on the island? Didn’t he say something to jJack about having been on the island all his life? Long enough to kidnap Rousseau’s baby and pretend she’s his child? How old is Ben anyway?

Finally, Kate doesn’t listen to Jack (as usual) and leads a commando raid to rescue him. When are they going to run out of guns? Didn’t their arsenal get blown up with the hatch?

See you next Wednesday and for the following fourteen Wednesdays on LOST.

LOST Rehash: I Do, or What Will Jack Do?

WARNING: Spoilers ahead. I use this space to discuss my thoughts and theories about the ABC-TV show LOST. If you haven’t seen the latest episode and odn’t want to know what happens, I suggest you run like Kate.

Finally, Jack grows a spine (and a brain) while working on Henry’s spine. Well, he hasn’t actually gotten to the spine or the tumor yet, but he does have a plan, and I’m on board for it. Actually, I can see a multitude of holes in Jack’s little plan, but I don’t think I could have come up with anything better, probably not anything nearly as good. However, just to show how smart I am, from the comfort of my living room with no one’s life riding on my decisions, I have a few questions for Mr. Jack to mull over for the next hour or the next three months —whichever comes first:

1. Why can’t the Others hold a gun on Jack and have Juliette stitch up the kidney? She is a doctor, isn’t she? Maybe she doesn’t know how to do surgery on a spinal tumor, but she could surely put a few stitches in a kidney, right?

2. What Jack doesn’t know of course, is that they’re supposedly on an island. What Jack does know is that whatever happens with Kate and Sawyer, he’s still stuck in the operating room with only a scalpel for a weapon. So, I’d say Jack’s in trouble, and Kate and Sawyer aren’t much better off.

3. If Kate and Sawyer will run, and if Mr. Wacko Bereaved Husband will let Sawyer go, and if they can get hold of a boat, Kate and James are home free. However, I can foresee that all this negotiating and finagling might take a little longer than an hour, might take until next February. And in that case, Henry/Ben is dead, and Jack no longer has a hostage.

4. What’s the range of those walkie-talkies? If K and S go to the other side of the water, will they even be able to notify Jack that they’ve made it?

So, Jack’s plan may or may not work, but it’s a good try.

Other Observations/Questions:

I don’t like Juliette. I don’t trust Juliette. Maybe she and Ben are allies, or maybe not. Either way, she’s just as creepy as he is.

What’s going on with Slingshot Girl? (I don’t remember her name.) Is she Rousseau’s Alex? Did I hear Ben ask about her asking about him just before he went under the anesthesia? When she asked to be taken to Ben, was it a take-me-to-your-leader request, or a what-have-you-done-with-Ben request?

Breaking rocks just seems stupid. And “I won’t work if Sawyer can’t come, too,” was sort of lame, too.

The Others must have let Jack get out, get a gun, see the monitors, see Kate and Sawyer. They’re still trying to play with his mind, but Jack shows them he’s not to be manipulated.

I think if I knew, as Sawyer and Kate are bound to know by now, that Big Brother was watching, I’d keep my clothes on. I think, under the circumstances, I’d keep my clothes on anyway. But self-control probably isn’t the forte of either of our lovebirds.

To change the subject a little, we now know that Eko died “for a reason” (other than to get him off the show?). So, the writers have three months to make up a reason if they don’t have one already. Locke and I are certainly not in on the secret if there is a reason. “Lift up your eyes and look to the north?” I don’t get the message, but Locke seems to have had a revelation.

De at Thinklings; “Sawyer hasn’t been beaten up, stabbed, shocked, operated on, or tortured yet [later edit: I forgot about the earlier cold-cocking by Danny. It’s hard to keep track of all the beatings, frankly]. Plus Kate loves him temporarily. Aside from the fact that he’s going to die tomorrow, he’s having a really good day.”
Cute.

We knew the writers of LOST would leave us with a cliff-hanger, and they did. My question to other viewers: was it exciting and intriguing enough to make you mark your calendar for February, 2007?

I’ll be back with more LOST hash in 2007. I want to see what happens to Ben and Juliette, and Charlie and Sayid. And I’m finally impressed with Jack although I still think Kate and Sawyer deserve each other —for better or for worse, probably worse. Jack can find a better mate. Not Juliette.