Archives

Sunday Salon: Books Read in March, 2009

The Sunday Salon.com
I read a LOT of books in March, mostly because I wasn’t blogging, but also because of some personal stuff going on in my life that enabled/forced me to sit in waiting rooms and and other waiting places regularly. I’ve written about most of these books in my Lenten journal, and I’ll be blogging those thoughts and reviews soon.

The School of Essential Ingredients by Erica Bauermeister. Recommended by Megan at Leafing Through Life. I sent my copy of this book to Eldest Daughter in Nashville after I finished it because she likes cooking and stories related to cooking. I think she’ll enjoy it as much as I did.

The End of the Alphabet by C.S. Richardson. Recommended by She Is Too Fond of Books.

Change of Heart by Jodi Piccoult. Recommended at the 3Rs.

The Amazing Potato by Milton Meltzer.

Alas, Babylon by Pat Frank. I’ve been reading a lot of apocalyptic, dystopian stuff lately; this one and several others fit that description.

The Compound –Bodeen. Recommended by Jen Robinson.

Star of Kazan—Ibbotson Recommended by Jen Robinson.

Stargirl by Jerry Spinelli.

Flipped by Wendelin Van Draanen. Recommended by Melanie at Deliciously Clean Reads.

Cutting for Stone by Abraham Verghese. Recommended at The Book Lady’s Blog.

Saving Juliet–Susan Selfors. Recommended by Melissa at Estella’s Revenge.

John Adams by David McCullough. The March Semicolon Book Club selection. If you’re participating in the book club and you posted about McCullough’s biography of John Adams, or even if you’re not doing the book club but you’ve written about this book, please leave a link in the comments. I’ll be posting my thoughts about the book this week, and I’ll be sure to link to yours.

Book by Book: Notes on Reading and Life by Michael Dirda. Recommended by Krin at Enough to Read.

Life As We Knew It–Pfeiffer Recommended by SassyMonkey.

Doomsday Book—Willis Recommended by Lazy Cow.

Maisie Dobbs by Jaqueline Winspear.

Birds of a Feather by Jaqueline Winspear.

Pardonable Lies by Jaqueline WInspear.

When Zachary Beaver Came to Town by Kimberly Willis Holt.

Careless in Red by Elizabeth George.

In the Woods by Tana French. Recommended by Kelly at BigAlittlea. Also recommended at Whimpulsive.

So Brave, So Young and So Handsome by Leif Enger.

22 books read in March.

The best fiction of March: Doomsday Book by Connie Willis. I am now reading the sequel, or book set in the same world, To Say Nothing of the Dog.

The best nonfiction of March: John Adams by David McCullough. I was inspired to not only watch the mini-series, which was very well done, but I’m also reading Alexander Hamilton by Ron Chernow, for a different perspective on the times.

Semicolon Book Club: January

We just adjourned the first meeting of the Semicolon Book Club for 2009. We discussed the two book selections for January:

Heaven by Randy Alcorn.

Heaven: Your Real Home by Joni Eareckson Tada.

There were only three of us in attendance, but we really enjoyed discussing the joys and possibilities of heaven, the place where we will live forever at home with the God who made us, redeemed us, and loves us eternally. I printed out this 2003 Christianity Today article by Peter Kreeft, and we discussed some of these “thirty-five frequently asked questions about eternity” in relation to the two books and to Scripture.

The most exciting idea that we talked about was the thought that not only will there be no more sin in heaven, but we will not have any desire to sin. Peter Kreeft writes about it like this:

Will we be free in Heaven? If so, will we be free to sin? If so, won’t anyone ever exercise that freedom?
“Freedom to sin” is a contradiction in terms, like “freedom to be enslaved.” Free choice is only the means to true freedom, “the freedom of the sons of God,” liberty.
In heaven we will not sin because we will not want to. We will freely choose never to sin, just as now great mathematicians do not make elementary mistakes, though they have the power to do so. In Heaven we will see the attractiveness of goodness and of God so clearly, and the ugliness and stupidity of sin so clearly, that there will be no possible motive to sin.
Now, we are enslaved by ignorance. Every sin comes from ignorance, for we sin only because we see sin as somehow attractive, which it is not, and goodness as somehow lacking in attraction. This is an ignorance that we are responsible for, but it is ignorance, and without that ignorance we would not sin. In Heaven, in the “beatific vision” of God, overwhelmed and filled with the total joy of goodness, baptized with goodness as a sunken ship is filled with water, no one could possibly ever want to turn from this perceived glory. Now, “we walk by faith, not by sight”(2 Cor. 5:7). Heavenly sight will not remove our freedom. Ask the blind whether sight would remove their freedom.

Can you imagine such perfect freedom? Joni talks about this kind of freedom in her book, too. Not only will she have a perfected body that will obey her will and mind and do all sorts of things that her now paralyzed body is unable to do, and not only will she have a perfected mind that will learn easily and happily and will enjoy both God and His creation, she will also have a perfected will that is perfectly in tune with that of the Creator, a will that only desires to do His will because we will be able to see Him face to face and understand that His will is always best.

And that’s why there will be no more tears. We will know HIm even as we are known.


Joni, in her book, playfully sets up meetings with friends and acquaintances: “I’ll meet you in Oregon for skiing and a cup of hot chocolate.” That kind of thing. I’m going to say that I’ll be in the Celestial Library, worshipping the Lord with my new mind (the one that doesn’t forget stuff), and I’ll meet anyone who wants to join me there to talk about all the wonders of what God has made.

If you are an online member of the Semicolon Book Club, or if you’re interested in joining in, the February selection is The Love Letters by Madeleine L’Engle. It’s out of print, but available, used, from Amazon sellers for a pittance. Just click on the cover picture to get to the Amazon page.

And here’s a special linky for those of you who posted about either Heaven by Randy Alcorn or Heaven: Your Real Home by Joni. Thanks for reading along.

1. Amy@Hope Is the Word (Joni Eareckson Tada)
2. Semicolon (Randy Alcorn)
3. Semicolon (Joni and Schuyler\’s Monster)
4. Carrie K. (Heaven, post 1)
5. Carrie K. (Heaven, post 2)

Powered by… Mister Linky’s Magical Widgets.

Schuyler’s Monster by Robert Rummel-Hudson

Schuyler’s Monster: A Father’s Journey With His Wordless Daughter.
Robert Rummel-Hudson’s blog: Fighting Monsters with Rubber Swords.

Yes, this book is about a little girl named Schuyler (pronounced Skylar) with a brain malformation called bilateral perisylvian polymicrogyria. This condition, probably congenital in Schuyler’s case, can cause several problems, but Schuyler’s main, most obvious problem is an inability to speak. The author, Schuyler’s dad, tries to focus on both Schuyler’s communication issues and her underlying vibrant personality. She comes across as a friendly, strong-willed, and somewhat mysterious little girl with a profound speech disablity.

However, the book is as much about the author himself as it is about Schuyler. Robert Rummel-Hudson is a self-described smart-ass and an agnostic. He’s funny and snarky, but his agnosticism is the theme that ties this autobiographical tale of a father together. He’s agnostic in regard to God and also in relation to a good prognosis and future for Schuyler. He doesn’t “have much use for Christianity” before Schuyler is born or diagnosed, but after he learns what her disability is called and what difficulties and suffering it involves, Mr. Rummel-Hudson becomes enraged with a God that he doesn’t really believe exists in the first place. If there were a God, he would be “God, my enemy, the bully who’d reached down and damaged my angel’s mind.” Schuyler’s dad can’t be an atheist because he sees that atheism requires as much faith as deism. However, since he has no faith, which he equates with certainty, he can’t believe in God or not believe. Nor does he believe that there is any purpose or meaning to Schuyler’s suffering. He is left with a vague Hope, a hope that, despite evidence to the contrary, he and his wife will be able to find someone or something that will help Schuyler to live a happy life, a fulfilling life. (Happiness and independence and fulfillment are the highest goods in Mr. Rummel-Hudson’s pantheon.)

YesI haven’t lived through anything nearly as tragic and difficult as Mr. Rummel-Hudson’s life with his daughter, Schuyler, so I can’t criticize his anger and hostility toward God, nor his later resignation to the idea that some kind of impotent God may exist and be unable to do anything to help Schuyler. I might very well feel the same way were I in his shoes. However, it’s interesting that I was also reading the first few chapters of Joni Eareckson’s book Heaven: Your Real Home today. In the book, Joni talks about her disability (paralysis) as both a curse and a blessing. She longs for heaven where she is assured of having a new body that will enable her to do all the things she can’t do here on earth. In that sense, she longs to escape her broken body that has brought her so much pain and suffering and denial of pleasure for so many years. However, she also says that her disability is, in a strange way, a blessing: “Somewhere in my broken, paralyzed body is the seed of what I shall become. The paralysis makes what I am to become all the more grand when you contrast atrophied, useless legs against splendorous resurrected legs. . . Whatever my little acorn shape becomes, in all its power and honor, I’m ready for it.”

Now, I’m not Joni either, and I’m not paralyzed or seriously disabled in any way. But I can see that we’re all broken in lots of ways, mentally, physically, and most of all spiritually, and that before we can “get fixed” we have to believe that there’s a Fixer and that He cares enough and is powerful enough to fix us, if not in this life, then someday in Heaven. And if Joni’s disability and suffering help her to know and trust the Fixer, then she’d say it’s worth it. That attitude isn’t much help to the agnostics of this world who, despite their need, are unwilling (not consciously needy enough?) to jump into the arms of the Only One who can meet that need. But Schuyler herself may grow up to see God and her need for Him in a way that her father can only hope to understand.

I pray that she does. And that her father, Mr. Rummel-Hudson, somehow comes to rely on God instead of a rubber sword.

Heaven by Randy Alcorn

Part 1: A Theology of Heaven

I started reading Randy Alcorn’s book, Heaven, the January selection for my Semicolon Book Club. I hate to admit it: I found the first part a little bit . . . boring. I think I must learn better through story than through exposition. I frequently find myself skimming through books that explicate Scripture, just as I zone out during sermons sometimes whether I intend to do so or not. It seems that I’ve heard most of this first part before, and I’m hoping to get to the “good part” soon, the part that tells me what I can expect heaven to be like.

Each sub-section begins with a question. I’ll give you a list so that you can see what I mean about having heard it before, and then you can know whether you should read the first part or skim it to get to the next part.

1. Are You Looking Forward to Heaven? Yes, I am. I know that lots of people have a misguided and uninformed idea of what heaven will be like. Clouds and harps and lots of singing. I don’t exactly have that problem, but I do have a somewhat “unformed” idea of what heaven will be like. I’m pretty sure it won’t be boring, and it won’t be repetitious, and it won’t be what I expect. But what will it be?

2. Is Heaven Beyond Our Imagination? Alcorn says no. “Everything pleasurable we know about life on Earth we have experienced through our senses. So, when Heaven is portrayed as beyond the reach of our senses, it doesn’t invite us; instead, it alienates and even frightens us. Our misguided attempts to make Heaven ‘sound spiritual’ (i.e., non-physical) merely succeed in making Heaven sound unappealing.”

3. Is Heaven Our Default Destination . . . Or Is Hell? Ouch. Most people think that they and their loved ones are headed for heaven. Unfortunately, the Bible says that ALL of us are headed for hell. Only those who grab onto life through the death and resurrection of Jesus Christ are destined for Heaven.

4. Can You Know You’re Going To Heaven? Yes. Romans 6:23 says, “For the wages of sin is death, but the gift of God is eternal life through Christ Jesus our Lord.” What a wonderful, life-giving promise!

5. What is the Nature of the Present Heaven? Alcorn distinguishes between what he calls “the Present Heaven.” the place where those who trust in Christ go as soon as they die, and the Future Heaven/New Earth, the place that God is preparing for all for his saints to live after the return of Christ. Alcorn’s Present Heaven sounds a lot like purgatory to me, but I’m sure he wouldn’t appreciate that identification.

6. Is the Present Heaven a Physical Place? Alcorn says yes. We are physical beings, with physical bodies, made to live in a physical place.

7. What Is Life Like in the Present Heaven? Based on Revelation 6:9-11, Alcorn says that the saints who have died have gone to a place where they remember their lives on earth, where they know what is happening on earth now, where they pray for those of us who are still on earth, and where they learn and have fellowship with God. It’s as if they’re on the outskirts of Heaven, and in C.S. Lewis’s image headed “further up and further in.”

The first two sections of Heaven give much more detailed answers to the above seven questions. The next section is about redemption in a cosmic, eschatological sense. I’ll write some more after I’ve read that part. In the meantime, what does your imagination conjure up when you hear the word “heaven”? What do you know to be true, or think to be true, about heaven?

12 Best Reading Lists of 2008

Jared’s Jesus Reading List at The Gospel-Driven Church. No, I haven’t read any of these, but I’d like to try to read at least one of the books on the list this year. Which one does anyone suggest I read first?

Image Journal’s 100 Writers of Faith. I’ve read thirteen of the 100 works listed, or at least attempted thirteen of them. I simply could not get through A Prayer for Owen Meany. I thought the style was annoying and the characters were not enjoyable. Some of the others on the list are favorites of mine, though, including Kristin Lavransdatter and Till We Have Faces and of course, The Lord of the Rings.

Lord Acton’s 100 Best Books, courtesy of Kevin Stilley. This list is good for making one feel uneducated and frivolous in comparison to the well-educated nineteenth century gentleman. Of the 100, I’ve read portions of four: Pascal’s Pensees, St Aungustine’s Letters, Dante’s Divine Comedy, and The Federalist Papers.

Season FIve of LOST premieres Wednesday January 21, 2009. To tide you over until then, ABC and the producers of LOST have a LOST book club with a list of all the books featured, pictured and referenced in the first four seasons. I’m still rather fond of this list at Coyote Mercury, and LOSTpedia also has a list with annotations and program notes. And here’s my LOST books post from last year.

Tullian Tchividjian’s Top 40 Books on Christ and Culture. This list is mostly, maybe all, nonfiction, and I’ve read very few of the books on the list. But I probably should read some of them.

The U.S. Presidents Reading Project has a list of all of the U.S. presidents and suggested reading selections (non-fiction) for each one. The challenge is to read one biography of each one.

Did you know that there’s a new edition of Peter Boxall’s 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die, and Arukiyomi has a new Excel spreadsheet for tracking your progress in reading the new list? My count for the old list from the first edition: 129. My count for the new list: Not sure yet?

The 100 Favorite Mysteries of the 20th Century as selected by the Independent Mystery Booksellers Association’s online members. I just found this list this year, so it’s new to me.

The Headmistress’s Worthwhile Reading Challenge with links to others’ lists of 12 worthwhile books to read in 2009.

The Conservative Exiles’ Reading List by Joseph Duggan in University Bookman. I may need to read some of these just to keep myself sane during an Obama administration.

Librarian Nancy Pearl DIps Below the Reading Radar. Almost all of these suggestions sound fascinating.

My very own Semicolon Book Club list which was compiled and finalized in late December 2008, and is now revealed to the sound of a drum roll:

January: Nonfiction inspirational (For January only there are two selections. Book club participants may choose to read either or both of the books.)
1. Heaven by Randy Alcorn. Tyndale House Publishers (October 1, 2004) $16.49 from Amazon.
2. Heaven: Your Real Home by Joni Eareckson Tada. Zondervan (October 10, 1997) $11.69 at amazon.

February: Christian classic novels
The Love Letters by Madeleine L’Engle. This book may be my favorite of Ms. L’Engle’s novels; it deals with marriage, faith, the meaning of love, and forgiveness, alternating settings between twentieth century Portugal and New York and a 17th century Portuguese convent.

March: Biography/History
John Adams by David McCullough. Simon & Schuster (January 29, 2008) 768 pages.
I plan to read this book and then watch the mini-series based on the book.

April: Poetry Month
All poems are about God, love or depression. Susan Wise Bauer in The Well-Educated Mind.
Paradise Lost by John Milton. “Recommended edition: The Signet Classic paperback, Paradise Lost and Paradise Regained, edited by Christopher Ricks. (New York: Signet Books, 1968, $7.95) This edition has explanatory footnotes at the bottom of each page. These are extremely helpful since Milton uses archaic expressions and hundreds of obscure classical references.” (SWB, The Well-Trained Mind)

May: YA or Children’s award winner
The Underneath by Kathi Appelt is the book I think will win the Newbery Award in 2009.

June: Chunky Classics
David Copperfield by Charles Dickens. 1024 pages.

July: Just for Fun and Adventure
River Rising by Athol Dickson.
River Rising is set in southern Louisiana, near the mouth of the Mississippi River, just before and during the Great Mississippi River Flood of 1927. The characters are residents of Pilotville, LA, a small town surrounded by swampland, and one stranger who comes to town to find out about his parentage. Hale Poser, the stranger, grew up in an orphanage, became a preacher, and now has come to Pilotville in hope of finding out something about his heritage. As soon as Rev. Poser hits town, strange things start happening, odd things like fruit growing where no fruit is expected to be, things that are attributable either to God or to chance or to Hale Poser the Miracle man. I’ve already read this book, but I’m looking forward to discussing it with a group.

August: Shakespeare play
Hamlet. Hamlet is a hero trapped by his own indecision in an insoluble quandary: should he take revenge on his father’s murderer or remain silent, tolerate evil, and live in a world that is “out of joint” —or perhaps commit suicide to escape it all?

September: Prize winning adult novel
Andersonville by MacKinlay Kantor.
Pulitzer prize winning Civil War novel brings to life the inmates and the masters of the notorious Andersonville Confederate prisoner of war camp.

October: Love to Laugh
Scoop by Evelyn Waugh. Scoop is a comedy of England’s newspaper business of the 1930s and the story of William Boot, a innocent hick from the country who writes careful essays about the habits of the badger. Through a series of accidents and mistaken identity, Boot is hired as a war correspondent for a Fleet Street newspaper. The uncomprehending Boot is sent to the fictional African country of Ishmaelia to cover an expected revolution. Although he has no idea what he is doing and he can’t understand the incomprehensible telegrams from his London editors, Boot eventually gets the big story.

November: Love to Think
A Walk with Jane Austen by Lori Smith. “In this engaging, deeply personal and well-researched travelogue, Smith journeys to England to soak in the places of Jane Austen’s life and writings. The book is sure to ride the wave of Austen-philia that has recently swept through Hollywood and a new generation of Americans, but this is an unusual look at Jane Austen. Readers will learn plenty of biographical details-about Austen’s small and intimate circle of family and friends, her candid letters to her sister, her possible loves and losses, her never-married status, her religious feelings, and her untimely death at the age of 41. But it is the author’s passionate connection to Jane-the affinity she feels and her imaginings of Austen’s inner life-that bring Austen to life in ways no conventional biographer could. Smith’s voice swings authentically between the raw, aching vulnerability of a single Christian woman battling a debilitating and mysterious chronic illness and the surges of faith she finds in the grace of a loving God.”
(Publisher’s Weekly review)

You are quite welcome to join in the Semicolon Book Club by leaving a comment or shooting me an email (sherryDOTearlyATgmailDOTcom). Just read along, and we’ll discuss toward the end of the month. The physical meeting time for those who live in the Houston area will be the fourth Saturday of the month at my house.

Twelve Projects for 2009

Last year instead of resolutions, I thought in terms of projects, lots of projects that I wanted to complete in 2008. I wouldn’t say I was any more or less successful with my projects than most people are with resolutions, but I like the tradition anyway and plan to to continue it this year. So here are my twelve projects for 2009, with evaluations of how I did on some of the same projects in 2008.

1. BIble Reading Project. Last year’s BIble reading project was a qualified success. I didn’t read every day, and I didn’t study the books and passages I chose as intensely as I wanted, but I did read and study some. This year’s BIble reading plan is the same as last year’s: choose a book or part of a book of the BIble for each month of the year, read it daily, and study it using some good study tools. Take notes in my Bible and maybe this year in a journal, too. The selections for this year:

January: II Samuel 1-8 Last year I read and studied I Samuel, so II Samuel seems to be next.
February: I Thessalonians
March: II Samuel 9-16
April: II Thessalonians
May: II Samuel 17-24
June: I Timothy
July: Joel
August: II TImothy
September: Amos
October: Titus
November: Psalms 1-5
December: Psalms 6-10

2. Pulitzer Project. This one will have to be a repeat from last year since I read only one of the books on my list, The Optimist’s Daughter by Eudora Welty. I didn’t review it because I didn’t really care for it much.

3. My Newbery Project for last year was also something of a bust. I think I got stuck because the winners for 1925 and 1926 were both story collections, and I don’t like story collections. I may skip the storybooks and get back on track this year.

4. My Madeleine L’Engle Project also failed to get off the ground last year. I think I just have so many good books to read, and not enough time. Anyway, this is another one I want to try again this year.

5. Operation Clean House. I figure if I take a room or area of the house and concentrate on that section each month, I might get somewhere with the de-cluttering and cleaning. Maybe.
January: My closet and dressing area.
February: The rest of my bedroom.
March: Front hallway and entryway.
April: Living Room.
May: Kitchen.
June: Laundry room.
July: Half of the gameroom.
August: The other half of the gameroom.
September: Front bathroom.
October: Z-baby’s bedrooom.
November: Karate Kid’s bedroom.
December: Sit back and enjoy my reorganized home?
I might even, if I’m brave enough, post before and after pictures to keep myself motivated.

6. LOST Reading Project. I really want to get back to this project this year.

7. The U.S. Presidents Reading Project has a list of all of the U.S. presidents and suggested reading selections (non-fiction) for each one. The challenge is to read one biography of each one. I would really like to start this project this year.

8. American History Project. In conjunction with the U.S. Presidents Reading Project, I’ll be teaching American history at home and at co-op next school year. So I’m working on planning a high school level literature/history class for co-op and condensing the Sonlight third and fourth grade curriculum suggestions for American history into one year for my little girls.

9. Poetry Project: I would like to get my urchins memorizing and reading poetry. I would like to read and memorize poetry. I would like to have more Poetry Parties.

10. Prayer Project. I need to spend some daily concentrated time in prayer and meditation. My plan is to pray and read my Bible before I get on the computer each day so that I can bathe all these projects and all my children and my husband in prayer.

11. Book Club Project. I’m really, really, truly starting my book club this year. We’re having our first meeting to discuss the books for the year this afternoon. If any of you are interested in participating (virtually), email me at sherryDOTearlyATgmailDOTcom, and I’ll send you the details. I’ll also be posting the book club selections for each month of 2009 here at Semicolon soon.

12. VIdeo Project. Engineer Husband and I are s-l-o-w-l-y watching the series Band of Brothers at night after the urchins are asleep. After we finish those videos, we’re planning to watch the HBO adaptation of David McCullough’s biography of John Adams, recommended here.

Bonus Project: I’ll keep blogging, the Good Lord willing and the creek don’t rise, and I’ll keep you all updated on all my projects for 2009.